Positive fantasies, mental contrasting and if-then plans
Popular writing about goals often recommends picturing a desired future as vividly as possible. A long-running research programme led by psychologist Gabriele Oettingen, at New York University and the University of Hamburg, has examined what happens when people do that. Its findings complicate the popular advice and connect to a second line of work, by Peter Gollwitzer, on planning.
Fantasies versus expectations
In a 2002 paper in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Oettingen and Doris Mayer separated two ways of thinking about the future. Expectations are judgements about how likely an outcome is, based on past experience. Positive fantasies are idealised images of the outcome itself. Across several studies, including students and university graduates looking for work, higher expectations predicted more effort and better outcomes, while more positive fantasies predicted less effort and worse outcomes. Graduates who reported more idealised fantasies about finding a job, for example, had received fewer job offers two years later.
A proposed explanation came from Heather Barry Kappes and Oettingen in 2011 (Journal of Experimental Social Psychology). Participants asked to fantasise positively about an upcoming week showed lower systolic blood pressure and reported feeling less energised than participants in comparison conditions. The authors interpreted this as the mind partly treating the imagined future as already attained. The physiological measure is indirect, and the interpretation remains a theory.
Mental contrasting
Oettingen's group then tested a different exercise: imagining a desired outcome and then imagining the main obstacle that stands in the way. This is called mental contrasting. In studies beginning with Oettingen, Pak and Schnetter (2001), participants who contrasted showed stronger commitment when they also had high expectations of success, and weaker commitment when expectations were low. The researchers describe this as helping people sort feasible goals from unfeasible ones, rather than raising motivation across the board.
Implementation intentions
Peter Gollwitzer, who is married to and frequently collaborates with Oettingen, developed the concept of implementation intentions: plans written in an "if situation X arises, then I will do Y" format. His 1999 article in American Psychologist set out the idea. In 2006, Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran published a meta-analysis in Advances in Experimental Social Psychology covering 94 independent tests. They reported a medium-to-large average effect on goal attainment (d = 0.65) compared with forming a goal without such a plan.
The two techniques were later combined into an exercise the researchers call MCII (mental contrasting with implementation intentions), and later popularised under the acronym WOOP: wish, outcome, obstacle, plan.
Limits and criticism
- Publication bias. Meta-analyses in social psychology can overstate effects when small studies with null results go unpublished. The 2006 estimate predates widespread pre-registration, and critics have argued the true average is likely smaller.
- Who ran the studies. A large share of the evidence comes from the originating research groups. Independent, pre-registered replications are fewer.
- Outcomes. Many studies measure short-term tasks or self-reported progress over weeks rather than long-term outcomes.
- Correlational designs. Some of the fantasy findings are correlational: people who fantasise more may differ in other ways that explain the outcome.
How the evidence is usually summarised
The research does not support the idea that imagining an outcome makes it more likely by itself; the 2002 and 2011 findings point, if anything, in the opposite direction for idealised fantasies. Pairing an outcome with its obstacles and a concrete if-then plan has more consistent support in laboratory and field studies, though the size of the benefit is uncertain and probably smaller than early estimates.
Sources
- Oettingen, G., & Mayer, D. (2002). The motivating function of thinking about the future: Expectations versus fantasies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 83(5), 1198–1212.
- Kappes, H. B., & Oettingen, G. (2011). Positive fantasies about idealized futures sap energy. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 47(4), 719–729.
- Oettingen, G., Pak, H., & Schnetter, K. (2001). Self-regulation of goal setting: Turning free fantasies about the future into binding goals. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 80(5), 736–753.
- Gollwitzer, P. M. (1999). Implementation intentions: Strong effects of simple plans. American Psychologist, 54(7), 493–503.
- Gollwitzer, P. M., & Sheeran, P. (2006). Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 38, 69–119.